2026 Benchmark Results

Subservicer Benchmark Findings

Anonymized aggregate findings from the industry's first independent subservicer satisfaction and performance index, based on data from 53 mortgage banking firms.

Key Findings

What 53 firms told us

27 pt
Satisfaction spread

A 27-point gap separates the highest-rated subservicer from the lowest on a 100-point composite index.

$12.7B
Recapture opportunity

HMDA data shows participants collectively left approximately $12.7 billion in recapture opportunity on the table.

25%
Never reviewed

One in four firms has never conducted a formal, independent evaluation of their subservicing relationship.

56%
Staying out of fear

More than half cite transfer risk and disruption as the primary reason they stay with their current subservicer.

Full Benchmark Portal

What you'll see with access

The findings portal is a secure, interactive view of the full anonymized benchmark. Subservicers appear as Peer A, B, C. No individual respondent data is exposed.

  • Composite satisfaction index across all respondents
  • Five-dimension breakdown: service quality, borrower experience, escrow and default, recapture support, operational friction
  • Question-level drill-down versus the anonymized peer field
  • Pain-point incidence rates across the cohort
  • Peer satisfaction distributions by subservicer
  • Custodial oversight and compliance benchmarks
  • Recapture opportunity sizing from public HMDA data
Access is gated. We verify every request to protect the data.
How We Can Help

Data is only as useful as the action it drives

Our advisory practice works with lenders on the problems the benchmark reveals.

Subservicer Oversight

Independent scorecard, oversight program review, contract and fee review, escrow and advance recovery, default oversight.

Subservicer Selection / RFP

A managed evaluation of the market with a written recommendation. If the right answer is to stay on better terms, that is exactly what we will tell you.

Profitability & Best Practices Review

110 areas across five disciplines, measured against a national peer group and the 70-plus lenders we review each year.

Recapture Playbook

Payoff autopsy on your last six months, one number for your board, and a prioritized list of what to fix first.

PULSE.

Ready to see the full benchmark?

Register for gated access to the complete anonymized findings portal, or book a call to discuss how the data applies to your organization.

Already have a link? Access the portal